The concept of learning to think like a lawyer is one of the cornerstones of legal education in the united states and beyond. The use of analogy in legal argument, cambridge up, 2005, e. Morrison, eds, the oxford handbook of thinking and reasoning 719, 731. To me not a lawyer but with some nexus to law, this book is not too hard to read, but i can tell that many points would not be easily understood without any legal experience. Professor frederick schauer examined whether thinking like a lawyer is unique to the legal profession at an alumni luncheon on april 30. We used firstyear students essays on thinking like a lawyer and their visual representations of their concept of law as a point of departure for a longitudinal case study of eight students. Many have written about learning to think like a doctor e. This is based on the idea that it is sometimes more important to build stability and take the values of the rule of law as important, than to make a perfectly accurate decision in the case at. Drawing on a wealth of sources, it shares key tips on how to stay afloat in an ocean of legal texts. A new introduction to legal reasoning by schauer, frederick. Welcome to thinking like a lawyer with your hosts elie mystal and joe patrice, talking about legal news and pop culture, all while thinking like a lawyer, here on legal talk network.
A new introduction to legal reasoning, by frederick schauer 2009 sydlawrw 20. Generally speaking, legal reasoning corresponds to thinking like a lawyer, but many interpretations have been attributed to this latter phrase james, 2012. Law students, law professors, and lawyers frequently refer to the process of thinking like a lawyer, but attempts to analyze in any systematic way what is meant by that phrase are rare. A new introduction to legal reasoning by frederick schauer in chm, fb2, fb3 download ebook. Good practice guide bachelor of laws thinking skills. In this book, jeffrey lipshaw provides a critique of the traditional views of thinking like a lawyer or pure lawyering aimed at lawyers, law professors, and students who want to understand lawyering beyond the traditional warrior metaphor.
Yet schauers book also offers the lawyer and scholar useful perspective on what he or she does. Thinking like a lawyer is by far the best available introduction to legal reasoning, of interest to law students and their teachers alike. Isbn 0674032705 hardbound, 9780674062481 paperback. A new introduction to legal reasoning schauer, frederick on. Arguments by legal analogy happen every day in courtrooms, law offices, and lawschool classrooms, and they are the essence of what we mean when we talk of thinking like a lawyer. A new introduction to legal reasoning and interrogates both the strengths as well as the shortcoming of the book in the context of contemporary.
Frederick schauer foreword of an introduction to legal. My 0l reading list law school, getting into law school. Thinking like a lawyer is excellent reading material for anyone wishing a deeper and more nuancedeven a more magnanimousunderstanding of the motivations behind laws often convoluted pronouncements. When taking the words of a statute seriously, when following a rule even when it does not produce the best result, when treating the fact of a past decision as a reason for making. The case study focused on the students impressions of the process of learning to think like a lawyer as revealed. Firstyear students must acquire a set of highly complex and interdependent cognitive skills in a. Anyone who has attended law school will recognize llewellyns description. Think like a lawyer using a legal reasoning grid and. A new introduction to legal reasoning and interrogates both the strengths as well as the shortcoming of the book in the context of contemporary legal education in common law countries. A lawyers guide to effective writing and editing gives you the specialized knowledge and techniques to draft clear and compelling legal documents, no matter how complicated the issues involved. The process of learning to think like a lawyer is dynamic and evolutionary.
In other words, the lawyer has categorized the facts of the clients situation as falling within the factual predicate of the rule. The notsohidden message that law professors give to their students is that to be a lawyer one must think like a lawyer, even if that means suppressing ones compassion, idealism, and concern for truth and justice. Further, it does not canvass reflective practice, which is another style of thinking incorporated in tlo 6 self. Stephen burton discusses the problem of overbreadth in highlighting the many issues a legal thinker might consider before applying a statute. Vandeveldes thinking like a lawyer first published, it became an instant classic, considered by many to be the gold standard introduction to legal reasoning.
In his book, thinking like a lawyer, schauer describes precedents to be previous decisions that should be followed in later cases for that sole reason. A new introduction to legal reasoning 18 2009 hereinafter schauer, thinking like a lawyer. The course reader is a set of supplementary photocopied materials, which will beavailable for purchase in copyvision in the basement lower level of the law school building, room 18. Levis, an introduction to legal reasoning, chicago up, 20, and raymond wackss philosophy of law. Users facultyoflawuniversityofsydneydesktoptorturing%20democracy. Studying law is not primarily about learning a bunch of legal rules, the law schools insist, for law has far more rules than can be taught in three years of legal education. Hello, welcome back to another edition of thinking like a.
The theory of rules, by karl llewellyn, edited and with an introduction by frederick schauer university of chicago press, 2011 thinking like a lawyer. Generally, they are expected to pick up this ability by example. The textbook is frederick schauer, thinking like a lawyer harvard university press, 2012. Students of the law are often told that they must learn to think like a lawyer, but they are given surprisingly little help in understanding just what this amounts to. Kniha thinking like a lawyer fredericka schauera z roku 2009. See frederick schauer, is there a psychology of judging. A new introduction to legal reasoning harvard university press, 2009, he has tried to explain that legal reasoningthinking like a lawyeris distinctive in its. Reasoning by legal analogy has been described as mystical, reframed by skeptics using the deductive syllogism, and called no kind of reasoning at all by judge posner. A new introduction to legal reasoning, professor frederick schauer teaches law students that american legal methods often require decisionmakers. John azzolinilaw library journal 02012010 a welcome complement to edward levis approach, as well as being easier for the legal novice to. But, if there is no anticipation that the nonlawyerlawyer relationship will actually turn into a formal lawyerclient relationship, not privileged attorneyclient privilege does not extend to disclosures made after the attorney refuse to undertake representation gionis. Thinking like a deal lawyer 225 closing date if the car has been driven more than an additional 500 miles.
Frederick schauer is the author of thinking like a lawyer 3. For example, sanson 2006 developed a narrow and broad definition of the phrase to think like a lawyer. In addressing the question whether legal reasoning is distinctive, frederick schauer emphasizes the formality and ruledependence of law. The identification of thinking skills as a minimum outcome of legal education is unlikely to be seen as contentious or controversial. Americans are taking new interest in legal reasoning. A new introduction to legal reasoning harvard university press, 2009 schauers text is described as a primer on legal reasoning written for law students. Montgomery, 2006 and learning to think like a lawyer e.
In this longawaited second edition, intended for fans of the original and a new generation of lawyers, vandevelde expands his classic work with useful revisions and updates throughout. Thinking like a lawyer frederick schauer harvard university. Many of the chapters in the book are concerned with the traditional first year topics. Besides, many of the legal rules that might be learned in law school will have been changed by legal reasoning. Which theory moralism, legalism, historicism or mod. Thinking like a lawyer is an essential guide for those starting out on their study of law. A new introduction to legal reasoning, by frederick schauer article pdf available october 2010 with 2,452 reads how we measure reads. The conclusion is that the legal consequence stated in the rule of law exists in the clients situation. Frederick schauers thinking like a lawyer, harvard up, 2012, lloyd weinribs, legal reason. We also serve the legal profession as it searches for ways to use technology and innovation to bridge the justice gap. A new introduction to legal reasoning frederick schauer this primer on legal reasoning is aimed at law students and upperlevel undergraduates. Brian leiter times literary supplement 20100212 thinking like a lawyer is excellent reading material for anyone wishing a deeper and more nuancedeven a more magnanimousunderstanding of the motivations behind laws often convoluted pronouncements. For illustrations of what thinking like a lawyer means, see generally frederick schauer, thinking like a lawyer.
According to schauer, american legal methods often require decisionmakers to do something other than the right thing. It should be enlightening to the general reader as well, who will learn what, for better and perhaps for worse, distinguishes thinking like a lawyer from other approaches to analyzing social problems. Thinking like a lawyer in the computer agelaw, 88 libr. Fred schauer on and sympathy with the role of rules in constraining decisionmakers. A new introduction to legal reasoning by professor frederick schauer suggests why. Vandevelde defines this elusive phrase and identifies the techniques involved in thinking like a lawyer. A new introduction to legal reasoning by frederick schauer, harvard university press, cambridge ma, 2009, 239pp, isbn 0674032705.
Thinking like a lawyer a new introduction to legal. You are now all well on your way to that magical state that is the end product of your first year in law school. Zorn, the federal income tax treatment of gambling. Thinking like a lawyer in the 21st century enhance and automate the audit, and we have helped to create a free version of the audit for law students.
All content included on our site, such as text, images, digital downloads and other, is the property of its content suppliers and protected by us and international laws. To answer the question, the deal lawyer must analyze the goal from both a. This paper adopts a narrow view of thinking like a lawyer focussing on legal reasoning rather than critical analysis or creative thinking. The book title, thinking like a lawyer, is a bit misleading on that point. Aimed at law students and upperlevel undergraduates, this primer on legal reasoning is also an original exposition of basic legal concepts that.
1440 369 1440 816 396 1376 809 622 296 1484 1405 581 45 1092 965 318 538 1 472 1130 964 1001 1007 248 1513 835 1617 1005 464 1488 748 135 637 380 588 1066 590 203 129 270 442 920 1136 997 1494 1243 1401 849 321 1258